| 
       
		As promised, here are some findings about 
		the 11-Plus examination derived from the two days I spent in March in 
		the Croydon local history archives. Again, my thanks to Archivist Chris 
		Bennett for all his help, and also to his assistant Chris Corner (who 
		was an old girl of Lady Edridge). Chris told me briefly of her time at 
		Lady Edridge, which coincided with the transition from being a grammar 
		school to a comprehensive. Evidently, she started at the school when it 
		was a grammar school but retains vivid memories of its demise! 
		
		  
		
		1944 Education Act 
		The 1944 Education Act introduced universal secondary education for the 
		first time in England and Wales, but it did not follow that educators 
		thought that all children should receive the same type of education. 
		Traditionally, the affluent middle and upper classes in Britain sent 
		their sons to public schools like Winchester, Rugby and Eton, and from 
		the latter stages of the 19th century, their daughters to the likes of 
		Cheltenham Ladies' College or Roedean. If they could not afford the fees 
		at the most expensive schools there were numerous other very highly 
		reputable private schools - like Whitgift and Croydon Girls' High School 
		- to which they could send their sons and daughters. 
   Throughout the 19th and the first half of the 20th century, 
		secondary education in England and Wales was directly associated with 
		social class or the capacity to pay. (What has changed, I hear you ask?) 
		It is true that some children from humble social origins were able to 
		attend such schools by winning scholarships of various types, but they 
		were a very small minority and often they had to leave prematurely when 
		their scholarship money ran out or their families could no longer afford 
		to pay the difference between the scholarship and the real costs of 
		sustenance. 
   Academic ability was another limitation on access to secondary 
		education. Even wealthy families might find access for their children to 
		a desired school prevented by the high standard of academic competition 
		for entry, although there were, of course, many "other" private schools 
		that provided a genteel environment for less able children. Secondary 
		education was traditionally geared towards entry to the professions, 
		which might or might not include entrance to university. 
   Moreover, prior to 1939 a "liberal" secondary education, which 
		still provided for a study of Latin, was not seen as the logical 
		extension of the elementary schooling provided for children of the lower 
		social orders. A high proportion of children who went to public and 
		other prestigious fee-paying schools did so after attendance at private 
		preparatory schools. In many instances the elite secondary schools ran 
		their own preparatory schools or junior classes. 
   In essence, then, there were two education systems operating in 
		England and Wales prior to the Second World War - one for the wealthy 
		and another, based on local council elementary schools, and central 
		schools like John Ruskin and Lady Edridge, for the rest! Given this 
		background, it is not hard to see that for many people the post war 
		prospect of universal secondary education heralded both an educational 
		and a social revolution, or did it! 
		
		  
		
		Study of human psychology 
		The first half of the 20th century witnessed a strong growth in 
		British and American universities of the study of human psychology, and 
		especially the study of human intelligence, which had obvious 
		educational implications. In the interwar years, British educational 
		psychologists were especially interested in the concept of IQ and how it 
		could be measured. 
   By the late 1930s it was widely believed that there was a common 
		"g" factor or intelligence quotient; that it was inherited and varied 
		from person to person; and that it could be measured by an array of 
		tests given to children at the age of about 11 or thereabouts. It was 
		also believed that children with a high "g" quotient were the most 
		intelligent, and therefore those most suited to attend university and 
		enter the learned professions or become leading administrators and the 
		like. Finally, it was also widely believed that it was manifestly 
		unfair, especially to the less able, to subject all children, regardless 
		of their level of intelligence, to the same type of schooling and a 
		common curriculum. 
   This was the logic which gave rise to the tripartite concept of 
		secondary education enshrined in the 1944 Education Act. All children in 
		state primary schools were to follow the same basic curriculum. In their 
		last year they would be tested to determine their IQ by means of a 
		battery of tests - what became universally known as the 11-Plus exam 
		although it consisted of several rather than one test. On the basis of 
		their IQ they were to be allocated to one of three types of school. In 
		theory, although not in practice, the top 25 percent were to be given a 
		grammar school education to enable them to attend university or to go 
		into professional careers of one sort or another. The next 10 percent, 
		adjudged to be suitable for work in technology and sub-professional 
		occupations, were to attend special technical schools. The remaining 
		60/65 percent, who it was thought would leave school at 15 to enter 
		adult employment, were to attend what became infamously known as 
		secondary modern schools. They were to offer a "broad general 
		curriculum" as a preparation for "so-called life" - whatever that meant. 
   Without going into detail one can summarize by saying that a true 
		tripartite system never eventuated because very few technical schools 
		were ever built. The perilous state of the national economy, and acute 
		shortages of raw materials for the building industry in the aftermath of 
		war, saw to that. In most parts of England and Wales children went to 
		grammar schools or secondary modern schools, but the ratios varied 
		greatly from one Local Education Authority to another. A child's chances 
		of attending a grammar school were generally higher if they lived in a 
		predominantly urban area like Croydon rather than in the Yorkshire 
		dales. This was because there were more schools in urban areas due to 
		the greater population. 
   Furthermore, boys had a greater chance of attending a grammar 
		school than girls because there were more boys' schools. This was partly 
		a legacy from the 19th century when boys were regularly sent to school 
		whereas girls were often schooled at home. It was only in the latter 
		stages of the 19th century that secondary schools for girls began to 
		proliferate but they were always fewer in number than the much longer 
		established boys schools. For example, Croydon Girls' High was 
		established in 1874 but boys' schools of comparable status like 
		Whitgift, Whitgift Middle and Dulwich College had in many instances been 
		established decades, even centuries, before. 
   Hopefully, this rather long introduction to the 11-Plus has not 
		bored you all to tears. It is, however, important to see the advent of 
		the 11-Plus and the role of John Ruskin Grammar School in the post-war 
		years in historical focus. 
		
		  
		
		Transition from Central School to 
		Grammar School 
		On 1 April 1945, John Ruskin Selective Central School changed its 
		status to that of John Ruskin Grammar School and henceforth entry was 
		based on the 11-Plus exam. Despite the singular term, the 11-Plus was 
		actually a battery of objective tests in English and arithmetic; a group 
		intelligence test; a spatial test; and a written English essay. The 
		tests had all been developed and standardised by Moray House, the 
		prestigious Scottish teacher-training college in Edinburgh, in the 
		1930s. Not all local education authorities used the Moray House tests 
		but a majority did, including Croydon. 
   Some of you may recall the English test and its components: a 
		comprehension exercise, correct use of words, rhymes and synonyms, 
		spelling, applied grammatical rules, and explanation or use of proverbs. 
		I certainly do because my class at Kensington Avenue primary school was 
		systematically prepared for the tests on a daily basis throughout the 
		autumn term of 1949. I have always thought that the ability to explain 
		the meaning of proverbs is an especially revealing exercise. Not only 
		does one need the "intelligence" to understand their often complex 
		meaning, but one also needs the equally complex linguistic skills to 
		convey their meaning via the written word. From memory, the spatial test 
		was similar to the Raven's Progressive Matrices test. This consists of a 
		series of patterns and you have to complete the black space. The Raven 
		Test was/is commonly used in the public service in recruiting staff. It 
		is a test that can, if required, extend even an Einstein to ultimate 
		distraction as it gets progressively more complex and difficult to 
		master. 
   The following is a list of Croydon schools that used the 11-Plus 
		and the number of places available for those who passed the exam in 
		January 1947. There were 14 schools (10 grammar schools and three 
		selective central schools). Croydon appears to have decided to maintain 
		its existing selective central schools on the grounds that they might 
		eventually be upgraded to grammar school status if there was sufficient 
		demand. This point needs further research to substantiate my conclusion, 
		but the elevation of Lady Edridge to grammar school status in 1951 lends 
		support to this belief. 
   I am not familiar with the history of all Croydon schools in the 
		late 1950s and early 60s. Perhaps someone else can explain what happened 
		to the other two selective central schools? 
   The number of places each school offered is placed alongside. 
  
		
			
				| 
				 
				Boys' Grammar Schools 
				  | 
				
				 
				Girls' Grammar Schools  | 
				
				 
				Selective Central School  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Whitgift   | 
				
				 
				14  | 
				
				 
				GHS   | 
				
				 
				34  | 
				
				 
				Lady Edridge  | 
				
				 
				61  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Whitgift Middle   | 
				
				 
				31  | 
				
				 
				Coloma   | 
				
				 
				75  | 
				
				 
				Heath Clark  | 
				
				 
				63  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Selhurst   | 
				
				 
				87  | 
				
				 
				Selhurst   | 
				
				 
				83  | 
				
				 
				Archbishop Tennison's  | 
				
				 
				31  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				John Ruskin   | 
				
				 
				58  | 
				
				 
				Old Palace  | 
				
				 
				33  | 
				
				 
				   | 
				
				 
				   | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Dulwich  | 
				
				 
				9  | 
				
				 
				St. Anne's   | 
				
				 
				7  | 
				
				 
				   | 
				
				 
				   | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				TOTAL  | 
				
				 
				199  | 
				
				 
				TOTAL  | 
				
				 
				232  | 
				
				 
				TOTAL  | 
				
				 
				155  | 
			 
		 
		
		 Lady Edridge was, of course, a girls' 
		school; Heath Clark was coeducational while Archbishop Tennison's was a 
		boys' school. In 1947, in the Croydon borough, there were clearly more 
		grammar school places available for girls than for boys, a scenario 
		which ran counter to the national scene. In subsequent years, Croydon 
		was also to establish a reputation for providing more grammar school 
		places than most other LEAs. 
   It should be noted that the figures quoted above are for places 
		available to children living in the Croydon borough. Dulwich College, 
		for example, also offered free places to children in other adjacent LEAs 
		like Wandsworth. Doubtless Whitgift did the same. The LEA records record 
		that in 1945 Whitgift Grammar changed its status from a direct grant to 
		a fully independent school - i.e. it ceased to receive government 
		financial assistance that had traditionally meant that it had to take 
		25% of its first form intake from 11-Plus pupils. Henceforth it agreed 
		to take 10% of its intake from 11-Plus pupils. 
   As a matter of passing interest, it was stated in the Croydon LEA 
		Minutes that it cost £51 per annum to send a child to Whitgift. By 
		contrast, Old Palace - a direct grant girls' school - charged annual 
		fees of £21 for girls over 10 years of age.    I will now 
		look in some detail at the 1950 report of the Chief Education Officer on 
		the admission of pupils to grammar and selective central schools in the 
		Croydon LEA. This will reveal the highly competitive nature of entrance 
		to Croydon's grammar schools. To simplify matters I will summarise the 
		report's relevant contents in point form. 
		
		  
		
			
				| 
				 1  | 
				
				 1450 
				boys and 1415 girls sat the 11 Plus - a total increase of 616 
				children over the previous year (1949).  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 2  | 
				
				 Most 
				children sat the tests in late January.  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 3  | 
				
				 
				Initially marking was done in the schools, then checked by a 
				Marking Panel, and finally all children's marks were 
				standardised.  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 4  | 
				
				 
				Children considered likely to 
				benefit from attendance at a grammar or selective  central 
				school were then called for interviews by the Heads of the 
				receiving schools and officers 
				
				of the Croydon LEA. 
				 | 
			 
			
				| 
				 5  | 
				
				 The 
				most striking fact to emerge from the results was that the mean 
				IQ figure for Croydon children who sat the Eleven Plus (107.6) 
				was substantially higher than that of any other LEA in the 
				country that used the Moray House tests. It was even higher 
				(107.6 as opposed to 106.3) than the mean score of the previous 
				year which was also the highest of those LEAs using the Moray 
				House tests. The Inspector's report went on to state that the 
				high intelligence figure for Croydon's children might well 
				justify more provision for selective secondary education in the 
				future. The national aim was to provide selective secondary 
				education for approximately 25 percent of children sitting the 
				Eleven Plus. The Croydon data for 1950 suggested that some 33 
				percent of Croydon children acquired an IQ score of 115 plus. If 
				this figure was maintained there would clearly be a need to 
				provide for more places in selective secondary schools within 
				the borough.  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 6  | 
				
				 
				When the test papers had been 
				marked the Head Teachers recommended 396 girls for the 245 
				grammar school places available. The comparable figure for boys 
				was 328 recommendations for 229 available places. For selective 
				Central schools the figures were 162 girls recommended for 90 
				places and 217 boys for 94 places. Clearly there keen 
				competition for places in both types of school. Given the total 
				numbers of girls and boys who sat the Eleven Plus, cited as 
				point 1, girls had roughly a 1 in 5 chance of getting a grammar 
				school place. For boys the odds were 1 in 6.  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 7  | 
				
				 
				57.6 percent of parents of 
				children who sat the Eleven Plus indicated a preference for a 
				grammar school type of education for their children. This 
				percentage was increasing annually. 
				
				Clearly many parents were doomed 
				to disappointment.  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 8  | 
				
				 The 
				1944 Act made provision for some children (late maturers) to 
				transfer from secondary modern schools to selective secondary 
				schools at age 13 if their academic performance merited a change 
				and if there were vacancies. In 1950, 3 children were 
				transferred to grammar schools and 25 to selective Central 
				schools. These figures suggest that there was little room for 
				transfers because very few children left grammar or central 
				schools before they were 15 or 16.  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 9  | 
				
				 The 
				following figures appeared in the 1950 report as Appendix B.  | 
			 
		 
		
		  
		
		Number of Children recommended for 
		transfer to Grammar and Selective Central Schools 
		
			
				| 
				 
				Boys' Grammar Schools 
				  | 
				
				 
				Girls' Grammar Schools  | 
				
				 
				Selective Central School  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Dulwich College  | 
				
				 
				20  | 
				
				 
				Croydon High School  | 
				
				 
				40  | 
				
				 
				Lady Edridge  | 
				
				 
				59  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Whitgift  | 
				
				 
				13  | 
				
				 
				St. Anne's College  | 
				
				 
				10  | 
				
				 
				Heath Clark  | 
				
				 
				61  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Whitgift Middle  | 
				
				 
				40  | 
				
				 
				Old Palace  | 
				
				 
				33  | 
				
				 
				Archbishop Tenison's  | 
				
				 
				64  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Selhurst Grammar  | 
				
				 
				90  | 
				
				 
				Selhurst Grammar  | 
				
				 
				89  | 
				
				 
				   | 
				
				 
				   | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				John Ruskin Grammar  | 
				
				 
				59  | 
				
				 
				Coloma Grammar  | 
				
				 
				71  | 
				
				 
				   | 
				
				 
				   | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				John Fisher, Purley  | 
				
				 
				5  | 
				
				 
				James Allen's   | 
				
				 
				2  | 
				
				 
				   | 
				
				 
				   | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				St. Joseph's College  | 
				
				 
				2  | 
				
				 
				   | 
				
				 
				   | 
				
				 
				   | 
				
				 
				   | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				TOTAL  | 
				
				 
				229  | 
				
				 
				TOTAL  | 
				
				 
				245  | 
				
				 
				TOTAL  | 
				
				 
				184  | 
			 
		 
		
		  
		
		The Croydon LEA Minutes also included the 
		1951 11-Plus results. In that year Croydon had the second highest mean 
		IQ score. Placements in grammar schools were as follows: 
		
		  
		
			
				| 
				 
				Boys' Grammar Schools 
				  | 
				
				 
				Girls' Grammar Schools  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Dulwich College  | 
				
				 
				19  | 
				
				 
				Croydon Girls'  | 
				
				 
				38  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Whitgift  | 
				
				 
				14  | 
				
				 
				St. Anne's College  | 
				
				 
				11  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Whitgift Middle  | 
				
				 
				40  | 
				
				 
				Old Palace  | 
				
				 
				39  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				Selhurst Grammar  | 
				
				 
				88  | 
				
				 
				Selhurst Grammar  | 
				
				 
				90  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				John Ruskin Grammar  | 
				
				 
				61  | 
				
				 
				Lady Edridge  | 
				
				 
				63  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				St. Joseph's College  | 
				
				 
				10  | 
				
				 
				James Allen's   | 
				
				 
				2  | 
			 
			
				| 
				    | 
				
				    | 
				
				 
				Coloma Grammar  | 
				
				 
				73  | 
			 
			
				| 
				 
				TOTAL  | 
				
				 
				232  | 
				
				 
				TOTAL  | 
				
				 
				316  | 
			 
		 
		
		
		 
		In the early 1950s, girls living in the Croydon borough continued to 
		have a major advantage over boys in acquiring grammar school places. How 
		this problem was overcome remains a matter for further research. 
		   Throughout the 1950s the 11-Plus generated ever increasing 
		discontent on the part of the parents who thought the selective process 
		disadvantaged their children, and from educators who challenged many 
		logic on which the process was based. When Harold Wilson's Labour 
		Government came to power in the early 1960s, it set about converting 
		grammar schools into comprehensives, a long drawn out saga which 
		signalled the demise of schools like John Ruskin Grammar School. 
		   In retrospect, schools like John Ruskin gave children from 
		lower socio-economic backgrounds the chance to "get on in life". Many of 
		the new grammar schools set high academic standards, especially with the 
		introduction of O- and A-level examinations which, in turn, were 
		reflected in much more intense competition to enter Oxford and Cambridge 
		and other leading English universities. 
   Some people look back on the 1950s as somewhat akin to a golden age 
		when grammar schools like John Ruskin flourished but like most things in 
		life, their success came at a price. The vast majority of children were 
		consigned to secondary modern schools - effectively an educational 
		cul-de-sac - and left school at 15. The 1944 Act did not produce an 
		educational revolution. The grammar schools certainly provided a ladder 
		of opportunity for the fortunate minority but English education still 
		continued to function largely on the basis of social class. What has 
		changed? 
   In retrospect, it would seem that the grammar schools took the 
		intellectual cream of the working and lower middle classes and schooled 
		them for five years in middle class values and aspirations, thereby 
		converting many of them into supporters of the Conservative 
		Establishment! No wonder the trade unions supported comprehensives! I 
		had better close on that note because I can already visualize heated 
		debate surrounding that statement.  
		   Before I do, the following points extracted from the 
		archives might be of interest to some of you. 
		
		1. An extract from the School logbook that 
		I don't think anyone has mentioned before: Mr. Lowe, the Headmaster, was 
		absent from school on 13 March 1951. Why? He was being interviewed for 
		the post of Headmaster at Epsom County Grammar School! 
		
		2. While at the Croydon archives I 
		hurriedly went through the admission registers for the period 1948-66. 
		According to my calculations there were 1970 boys admitted, of whom 31 
		left due to emigration abroad. 13 went to Australia; four to New 
		Zealand, eight to Canada, three to the USA, and three to Southern 
		Rhodesia. A further 63 were cited as going on to university. This figure 
		may have been marginally greater as some entries did not indicate where 
		to from school, but clearly the overwhelming majority of the 1970 boys 
		who attended John Ruskin during those years DID NOT go on direct to 
		university. Frankly, I was surprised. I would have thought far more did 
		so. 
		
		3. If, like me, you went to John Ruskin 
		after attending Kensington Avenue primary school, which was established 
		in 1932, you may be interested to know that in the period 1948-66 there 
		were 30 of us who shared that dubious distinction. I appeared to be the 
		only one in 1950. 
		
		   Warmest regards to all of you 
		who take the trouble to read about the 11-Plus. Your own memories of the 
		experience of sitting would be a most valuable addition to what I have 
		written. 
		
		
		Clive Whitehead, Perth, Western Australia, June 2005 
		email  |